as was discussed on my comment section for yesterday's post, there was some disappointment expressed about my not talking about my Oregon T-Shirt diet. being as i am very attentive to the concerns of William Oram, i am of course not going to talk about it today either. instead let's play a game.
yesterday, i was talking to Robyn and randomly i asked her who sang the better "How Do I Live," Trisha Yearwood or Leann Rimes? for those of you not familiar with the 90s country music circuit, both these ladies released this song in 1997 and both became hits and both were nominated for a Grammy. Yearwood's version won the Grammy while Rimes' broke a record for most weeks on the charts.
Ro's answer was Yearwood's version while i kind of have to go with the Rimes. so that got me thinking about cover songs and who sung what version better? after exchanging some ideas with Robyn, i have compiled a list of 15 songs that have been sung by more than one artist and who i think had the better version.
agree? awesome. disagree? well, that's why you don't write for this blog.
Who Sang It Better?
1. “I Will Always Love You” – Whitney Houston or Dolly Parton
- duh. the answer to this one is Whitney. if you disagree, you should probably quit reading this right away and go get your ears checked.
2. “Respect” – Aretha Franklin or Otis Redding
- i do like me some Aretha but i've got to go with the original on this one. Otis is the man.
3. “What’s Going On” – Marvin Gaye or the Plethora of Pop Stars
- while i am a fan of anything that features blindfolds and Christina Aguilera, Marvin Gaye's version is one of the five greatest songs of all-time. so we go with Marvin.
4. “Landslide” – Fleetwood Mac, Smashing Pumpkins or the Dixie Chicks
- the Dixie Chick's version is probably the only post-2000 country song that i've liked.
5. “Sexual Healing” – Ben Harper or Marvin Gaye
- the Ben Harper version is great and a mood-setter but Marvin gets the nod here solely for the music video. balla.
6. Hallelujah” – Jeff Buckley or Leonard Cohen
- i think Jason Castro's version is even better than Cohen's. Jeff Buckley's version is 6 1/2 minutes of haunting brilliance.
7. “Smooth Criminal” – Michael Jackson or Alien Ant Farm
- Ro thinks the AAF cover is better. i disagree... a lot. you can't disrespect the King of Pop like that.
8. “Time After Time” – Cyndi Lauper, Blaque, Quietdrive or INOJ
- i have nothing bad to say about the Cyndi version (it is afterall the song that reminds me the most of my relationship with the only girl i've really ever loved) but the INOJ version is just better. it's awesome.
9. “Heaven” – Bryan Adams, Yanou or DJ Sammy f/ Yanou
- i refuse to vote for Canada on this one so let's go with Yanou because the DJ Sammy one is just a little too much funk for a song like this.
10. “When You Say Nothing At All” – Ronan Keating, Alison Krause or Keith Whitley.
- probably the toughest call on the board... and we've got to go with Allison Krause on this one. i dunno, this song just sounds better and more real when a female is singing it. i actuallly first heard this song (the Roman Keating version) in 5th grade and i suggested that it be the song for a couple of friends who were "dating." it became their song and they then broke up soon afterwards. forever only lasts a few months when you're a pre-teen.
11. “Every Breath You Take” – The Police or Puff Daddy
- i want the Puff/Puffy/Diddy Daddy version (actually named "I'll Be Missing You") played at my funeral (sandwiched between Forever Young and Amazing Grace). i want Sting nowhere near my casket.
12. “Right Here Waiting” – Richard Marx or Monica f/ 112 - when i want great music i look for the "Totally Hits" CDs... which is where i found the Monica cover.
13. My Perogative” – Britney Spears or Bobby Brown
- Bobby. Brown.
14. “What Hurts The Most” by Rascal Flatts, Cascada or the UNC Clef Hangers
- i will give a shout-out version to the Clef Hangers here. they do a really good rendition, it's a shame they aren't on the iTunes.
15. “Candle In The Wind” by Elton John (for Marilyn Monroe) or Elton John (for Princess Di)
- maybe it's just my anti-Diana bias here but i really like the original version dedicated to Marilyn Monroe more.
so that's my game. i hope you stayed awake for the entire thing.
The Move
6 hours ago





